THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE CRIMINAL LAW: THE EVOLUTION OF RESEARCH, WAYS TO SOLVE PROBLEMS

УДК 343.21 ББК 67.408–32

  • V. I. Plokhova Altai State University Barnaul, Russia
DOI_disc_logo https://doi.org/10.14258/ralj(2025)2.13
Keywords: components, effectiveness, purpose, result, conditions, quantitative, qualitative, research improvement, evaluation stages

Abstract

As a result of the assessment, the available studies of the effectiveness of various criminal law phenomenarevealed unacceptable ones (ignoring goals, qualitative indicators, etc.). and progressive provisions to be usedin the study of the effectiveness of any legal phenomena. Methods of economic analysis, for example, areof interest to researchers of criminal law from the standpoint of the economic state of society, to determinethe facet of criminal-criminal in economic crimes, to predict the effectiveness of criminal law. The use ofAI complements traditional ways of assessing the effectiveness of legal phenomena with modern tools andnew methods for calculating quantitative indicators. It is also concluded that to date, the institute of theeffectiveness of the criminal law has not been sufficiently studied: many issues are debatable, others have notbeen noticed or evaluated; the disparity of research on various aspects, levels of effectiveness of the criminallaw, law, and its structural elements is obvious. A complete picture of the effectiveness of the criminal law canbe provided by a study of effectiveness in relation to each and every element of it: the overall effectiveness ofthe criminal law, institution, group of norms, corpus delicti, punishment; disposition, sanctions; in relation to the qualitative and quantitative side of this institution; at all stages of life norms (justifications of the criminallaw): lawmaking, implementation — application, execution (criminalization, penalization, etc.). They are notthe same for different levels of research on the effectiveness of the criminal law, they are specific at each stage

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

1. Кудрявцев В.Н., Никитинский В.И., Самощенко И.С., Глазырин В.В. Эффективность правовых норм. М. : Юрид. лит., 1980. С. 22
2. Плохова В.И. Эффективность нормы, предусматривающей ответственность за хищение социалистического имущества путем присвоения, растраты либо злоупотребления служебным положением : дис. … канд. юр. н.: 12.00.08. Свердловск, 1978.
3. Эффективность правового регулирования : монография / М.В. Антонов и др. ; под общ. ред. А.В. Полякова и др. М. : Проспект, 2017. 239 с.
4. Эффективность российского уголовного законодательства (теоретико-прикладное исследование) : монография / В.Н. Сизова ; под науч. ред. А.П. Кузнецова. М. : Юрлитинформ, 2015. 170 с.
5. Сизова В.Н. Эффективность российского уголовного законодательства (теоретико-прикладное исследование (анализ)) : дис. … канд. юр. н. Н. Новгород, 2012. 217 с.;
6. Бытко С.Ю., Варыгин А.Н. Некоторые методологические вопросы оценки эффективности предупредительного воздействия уголовных наказаний // Вестник Пермского университета. Юридические науки. 2019. Вып. 43. C. 146–177.
7. Фролова С.М. Эффективность исправительных работ как вида уголовного наказания, применяемого к несовершеннолетним : дис. … канд. юр. н. Томск, 2013.
8. Яхшибекян Э.Н. Эффективность исполнения, отбывания наказания в виде обязательных работ : дис. … канд. юр. н. М., 2012.
9. Бытко С.Ю. Уголовное наказание: сущность и эффективность предупредительного воздействия: монография. М. : Юрлитинформ, 2016. 312 с.
10. Бытко С.Ю. Эффективность предупредительного воздействия уголовного наказания на преступность: теоретический и прикладной аспекты : дис. … д-ра юр. н. Саратов, 2019. 471 с.
11. Бабурин В.В., Тарбагаев А.Н., Сурихин П.Л. Эффективность уголовно-правовой нормы: системный подход // Гуманитарные науки. 2023. №16 (5). С. 690–704.
12. Жалинский А.Э. Анализ и оценка эффективности предупреждения преступности // Теоретические основы предупреждения преступности. М. : Юрид. лит., 1977. 256 с.
13. Рагимов И.М. Эффективность наказания: «Цель — Результат» // Юридические науки и образование. 2020. №62. С. 160.
14. Насреддинова К.А., Камалетдинова Э.Р. Эффективность назначения и исполнения наказания в виде лишения свободы // Вестник Самарского юридического института. 2019. №3 (34). С. 144–148.
15. Чураков В.Д. Методы экономического анализа права и больших данных в оценке эффективности правовых норм : дис. … канд. юр. н. М., 2023. 201 c.
16. Суходолов А.П., Иванцов С.В., Молчанова Т.В., Спасенников Б.А. Big Data как современный криминологический метод учения и измерения организованной преступности // Всероссийский криминологический журнал. 2019. Т. 13. №5. C. 718–726.


REFERENCES
1. Kudryavtsev V.N., Nikitinsky V.I., Samoshchenko I. S., Glazyrin V.V. Effectiveness of legal norms. M.: Yurid. lit., 1980. P. 22
2. Plokhova V.I. Effectiveness of the norm providing responsibility for theft of socialist property by means of misappropriation, embezzlement or abuse of office: thesis … Candidate of Law: 12.00.08. Sverdlovsk, 1978.
3. The effectiveness of legal regulation: a monograph / M.V. Antonov et al; under the editorship of A.V. Polyakov et al. M.: Prospect, 2017. 239 p.
4. Effectiveness of Russian criminal legislation (theoretical and applied research): a monograph / V.N. Sizova; under the scientific editorship of A.P. Kuznetsov. M. w: Yurlitinform, 2015. 170 p.
5. Sizova V.N. Efficiency of Russian criminal legislation (theoretical and applied research (analysis)): thesis. … c. j. n. Nizhny Novgorod, 2012. 217 p.
6. Bytko S.Y., Varygin A.N. Some methodological issues of assessing the effectiveness of the preventive impact of criminal penalties // Bulletin of Perm University. Juridical sciences. 2019. Vyp. 43. P. 146–177.
7. Frolova S. M. Efficiency of corrective works as a type of criminal punishment applied to minors: dis. … c. j. n. Tomsk, 2013.
8. Yakhshibekyan E.N. Efficiency of execution, serving punishment in the form of compulsory works: Cand. Candidate of Y.Y. N. M., 2012.
9. Bytko S.Y. Criminal punishment: the essence and effectiveness of preventive impact: monograph. M.: Yurlitinform, 2016. 312 p.
10. Bytko S.Y. Effectiveness of the preventive impact of criminal punishment on crime: theoretical and applied aspects: thesis. … doctor of juridical science Saratov, 2019. 471 p.
11. Baburin V. V., Tarbagaev A. N., Surikhin P. L. Efficiency of criminal-legal norms: a systematic approach // Humanities. 2023. №16 (5). P. 690–704.
12. Zhalinsky A. E. Analysis and evaluation of the effectiveness of crime prevention // Theoretical foundations of crime prevention. M.: Yurid. lit., 1977. 256 p.
13. Ragimov I.M. Efficiency of punishment: “Purpose — Result” // Legal Sciences and Education. 2020. №62. P. 160.
14. Nasreddinova K.A., Kamaletdinova E.R. Effectiveness of the appointment and execution of punishment in the form of deprivation of liberty // Bulletin of Samara Law Institute. 2019. №3 (34). P. 144–148.
15. Churakov V.D. Methods of economic analysis of law and big data in assessing the effectiveness of legal norms: dis. … c. j. n. M., 2023. 201 p.
16. Sukhodolov A. P., Ivantsov S. V., Molchanova T. V., Spasennikov B. A. Big Data as a modern criminological method of teaching and measuring organised crime // All-Russian Journal of Criminology. 2019. Т. 13. №5. P. 718–726.
Российско-азиатский правовой журнал
Published
2025-07-07
How to Cite
Plokhova V. THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE CRIMINAL LAW: THE EVOLUTION OF RESEARCH, WAYS TO SOLVE PROBLEMS // Russian-Asian Law Journal, 2025, № 2. P. 87-93 DOI: 10.14258/ralj(2025)2.13. URL: https://ralj.ru/article/view/%282025%292.13.
Issue
No 2 (2025): Russian-Asian Law Journal
Section
CRIMINAL LEGAL STUDIES

Copyright (c) 2025 В. И. Плохова

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Russian-Asian Law Journal is a golden publisher, as we allow self-archiving, but most importantly we are fully transparent about your rights.

Authors may present and discuss their findings ahead of publication: at scientific conferences, on preprint servers, in public databases, and in blogs, wikis, tweets, and other informal communication channels.

Russian-Asian Law Journal allows authors to deposit manuscripts (currently under review or those for intended submission) in non-commercial, pre-print servers such as ArXiv.

Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:

  1. Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
  2. Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
  3. Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).